Please see the 2021 Municipal Equality Index scorecard available here.
The following outlines our standards for credit in each section of the 2021 Municipal Equality Index (MEI) scorecard. Please note that we have strengthened our standards for credit in Part II(B) - Transgender-Inclusive Healthcare Benefits. In total, the MEI will reflect 100 standard points and 22 flex points.
SECTION I. NON-DISCRIMINATION LAWS
Non-Discrimination in Private Employment, Housing, and Public Accommodations (Up to 30 points). This category evaluates whether a city has an enforceable non-discrimination ordinance that expressly covers sexual orientation and gender identity and applies to private employment, housing, and public accommodations citywide. In each category (private employment, housing, and public accommodations), cities receive 5 points for explicitly prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and 5 points for expressly prohibiting discrimination on the basis of gender identity. A 3-point deduction is applied for protections that contain carve-outs prohibiting individuals from using facilities consistent with their gender identity. Up to six points will be deducted for religious exemptions that single out sexual orientation and/or gender identity.
Flex: All-Gender Single-Occupancy Facilities (2 flex points). Cities that require all single-user sex-segregated facilities within the city like bathrooms and changing rooms to be all-gender will receive two flex points. Cities that designate all single-occupancy facilities within their own buildings as all-gender will receive half credit. For more information on the importance of equal access to single-occupancy facilities, see our issue brief entitled, Equal Access to Sex-Segregated Facilities, on the MEI home page, www.hrc.org/mei.
Flex: Protects Youth from Conversion Therapy (2 flex points). Cities that enact laws to protect youth from the harmful and discredited practice of so-called “conversion therapy”—any effort to change an individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity—will garner two flex points. To learn more about this dangerous practice, see our issue brief entitled, Protecting Youth from Harmful “Conversion Therapy,” on the MEI home page, www.hrc.org/mei.
SECTION II. MUNICIPALITY AS EMPLOYER
Non-Discrimination in City Employment (7 points for sexual orientation/7 points for gender identity). Whereas Section I assesses private employment citywide, this section evaluates non-discrimination protections for city employees (public employment). To qualify for credit, the city must have an enforceable non-discrimination ordinance or policy that expressly applies to all municipal employees and explicitly includes sexual orientation and gender identity.
Transgender-Inclusive Healthcare Benefits (6 points). To obtain credit in this category, the city must offer at least one municipal employee health insurance plan that expressly covers transgender healthcare needs, including gender-affirming surgical procedures, hormone therapy, mental health care, and all related medical visits and laboratory services. The lack of express exclusions for these services is not sufficient for credit because this care is routinely not covered. The plan should also ensure coverage of routine, chronic, or urgent non-transition services and eliminate other barriers to coverage including, but not limited to, separate dollar maximums and exclusions for covered dependents. Moreover, all out-of-network gender-affirming care for which in-network care is unavailable should be covered on the same terms as out-of-network coverage for other types of necessary care. For more information on extending transgender-inclusive health care benefits to city employees, read our issue brief on the MEI home page, www.hrc.org/mei.
City Contractor Non-Discrimination Ordinance or Policy (3 points for sexual orientation/3 points for gender identity). This refers to a city law or policy that requires all businesses the city contracts with for goods or services to have an employee non-discrimination policy that expressly covers sexual orientation and gender identity. Partial credit may be awarded in instances where the city has no qualifying ordinance or policy but consistently includes a contractor non-discrimination provision in all contracts with businesses, or when a city gives a bidding preference to businesses with a qualifying employee non-discrimination policy.
Inclusive Workplace (2 points). This section assesses whether a municipality has LGBTQ+-specific programming to attract LGBTQ+ applicants and promote diversity in the workplace. Cities will receive credit if they have any one of the following: an LGBTQ+ employee resource group open to all city employees, LGBTQ+-inclusive diversity training for all city staff, or a recruitment program that actively advertises available positions to the LGBTQ+ community.
Flex: City Employee Domestic Partner Benefits (1 flex point). Cities will receive credit for offering equal benefits to both same- and different-sex domestic partners of city employees and their legal dependents. Even after nationwide marriage equality, it is important to respect the diverse family forms that exist by expanding domestic partner benefits to include all families. For more information on this topic, see our issue brief entitled, The Case for Retaining Domestic Partnership Laws and Policies, on the MEI home page, www.hrc.org/mei.
SECTION III. MUNICIPAL SERVICES
Human Rights Commission (5 points). Credit is awarded in this section if the city has a community-facing body tasked with eliminating discrimination and educating the public on issues of diversity and inclusion. To these ends, the commission can hold community discussions, screen movies, present panels, take public comments, advise city leaders and develop policies and strategies to make the city more inclusive. The commission must be active and meet regularly.
Non-Discrimination Ordinance Enforcement by Human Rights Commission (2 standard points). Where, in addition to the functions listed above, a Human Rights Commission has the authority to conciliate, issue a right to sue letter, or otherwise enforce citywide non-discrimination protections, that commission will earn two standard points.
LGBTQ+ Liaison in the City Executive's Office (5 points). To earn credit in this category, the city must have an officially designated liaison to the LGBTQ+ community who reports to the city executive and whose designation as LGBTQ+ liaison and contact information is posted on the city website. An LGBTQ+ liaison serves as an accessible and friendly ear to the city’s LGBTQ+ community and elevates LGBTQ+-related concerns to the city executive and other city officials. LGBTQ+ persons who work in the city executive’s office do not qualify for credit in this category unless they serve as the official LGBTQ+ liaison and meet the above criteria. This role may be assigned to existing city staff. Additionally, the LGBTQ+ liaison to the city executive cannot double for credit as an LGBTQ+ police liaison (which is rated in Part IV), given the unique function of each of these divisions of city government.
Flex: Youth Bullying Prevention Policy for City Services (1 flex point for sexual orientation/1 flex point for gender identity). This category awards cities up to two flex points for implementing policies that prohibit bullying on the express basis of sexual orientation and gender identity in all youth-facing city facilities, activities, programs, and services. These policies should cover, for example, the city’s parks and recreation department, library programs, and any other department or service that incorporates young people. For more on this topic, see our issue brief entitled, Inclusive and Innovative Approaches to Citywide Bullying Prevention, on the MEI home page, www.hrc.org/mei.
Flex: City provides services to/supports LGBTQ+ youth (2 flex points). Cities should offer services designed to address the unique needs of LGBTQ+ youth, who often face higher rates of bullying, harassment, and rejection after coming out. Cities can earn credit here by (1) directly providing services targeted to LGBTQ+ youth, (2) funding organizations that provide these services, OR (3) providing other meaningful types of support (such as in-kind support, subsidized use of city facilities, etc.) to community organizations that provide services designed for LGBTQ+ youth. For LGBTQ+ youth resources, visit http://www.hrc.org/resources/lgbtq-youth.
Flex: City provides services to/supports LGBTQ+ people experiencing homelessness (2 flex points). LGBTQ+ people – particularly youth – are disproportionately more likely to experience homelessness. Cities can earn credit in this section by (1) directly providing services targeted to LGBTQ+ people experiencing homelessness, (2) funding organizations that provide these services, OR (3) providing other meaningful types of support (such as in-kind support, subsidized use of city facilities, etc.) to community organizations that provide services or resources targeted to LGBTQ+ people experiencing homelessness.
Flex: City provides services to/supports LGBTQ+ older adults (2 flex points). As LGBTQ+ individuals age, they encounter unique health, social and cultural challenges. Cities can earn credit in this section by (1) directly providing services targeted to LGBTQ+ older adults, (2) funding organizations that provide these services, OR (3) providing other meaningful types of support (such as in-kind support, subsidized use of city facilities, etc.) to community organizations that provide services or resources targeted to LGBTQ+ older adults.
Flex: City provides services to/supports people living with HIV or AIDS (2 flex points). HIV continues to disproportionately impact segments of the LGBTQ+ community. Cities can earn credit in this section by (1) directly providing services for people living with HIV or AIDS, (2) funding organizations that provide these services, OR (3) providing other meaningful types of support (such as in-kind support, subsidized use of city facilities, etc.) to community organizations that provide services or resources targeted to individuals living with HIV or AIDS. For resources on HIV and AIDS, visit https://www.hrc.org/resources/hrc-issue-brief-hiv-aids-and-the-lgbt-community.
Flex: City provides services to/supports the transgender community (2 flex points). Transgender individuals face disproportionate levels of discrimination, stigma, and systemic inequality. Cities can earn credit in this section by (1) directly providing services targeted to transgender residents such as employment programs, post-incarceration re-entry programs, and violence prevention programs; (2) funding organizations that provide these services; OR (3) providing other meaningful types of support (such as in-kind support, subsidized use of city facilities, etc.) to community organizations that provide services or resources targeted to the transgender community. For resources on the transgender community, please visit http://www.hrc.org/resources/transgender and review the issue brief entitled, Anti-Transgender Violence: What Cities Can Do, available here or at www.hrc.org/mei.
SECTION IV. LAW ENFORCEMENT
LGBTQ Police Liaison or Task Force (10 points). To get credit in this category, the city must have an officially designated liaison from the police department to the LGBTQ community (or a police task force charged with addressing LGBTQ issues) whose designation as LGBTQ liaison and contact information is posted on the police department’s website. An LGBTQ police liaison serves as an accessible and friendly ear to the city’s LGBTQ community and elevates LGBTQ-related concerns to the police chief and other city officials. LGBTQ police officers, including high-ranking officers, do not qualify for credit in this category unless their service as liaison is part of their official job and the required information is published online. Partial credit will be awarded if the entire police force was recently trained on LGBTQ issues.
Reported 2019 Hate Crimes Statistics to the FBI (12 points). To qualify for points in this section, the city must report hate crimes statistics to the FBI in all categories, including sexual orientation and gender identity, and either:
Report a positive number of hate crimes in any category in 2019 (i.e. report more than “0” for hate crimes reported in any one or more of the protected categories), OR
Report zero hate crimes in 2019 AND have reported a positive number of hate crimes in any one or more of the protected categories some year in the past five years of published reports. This second prong is to recognize that while statistically, it is possible that no hate crimes of any kind occurred in a small city one year, it is highly improbable that no hate crimes of any kind occurred in a city in the past five years of published FBI hate crimes reports.
SECTION V. LEADERSHIP ON LGBTQ+ EQUALITY
Leadership’s Public Position on LGBTQ+ Equality (0-5 points). This section grades, on a sliding scale from zero to five points, how pro-equality the city leadership is in its public statements. City leadership includes the city executive, city council, and other government officials. These statements may include joining a pro-equality association such as Mayors Against LGBTQ+ Discrimination, coming out publicly in favor of LGBTQ+ rights, supporting LGBTQ+ community organizations publicly, attending a pride parade, speaking out against anti-LGBTQ+ legislation, partnering with LGBTQ+ groups to create solutions to city problems, etc. It also includes comments made during city council meetings or at other public events.
Leadership’s Pro-Equality Legislative or Policy Efforts (0-3 points). This section grades, on a sliding scale from zero to three points, how actively the city has been pursuing pro-equality legislation and policies. This includes ordinances introduced (whether passed or not), city policies, and pro-equality city council resolutions and proclamations.
Flex: Openly LGBTQ+ Elected or Appointed Municipal Officials (2 flex points). Appointed or elected city officials who are openly LGBTQ+ will qualify the city for two flex points in this category. While the city should seek to employ LGBTQ+ persons at all levels of government, this criterion specifically addresses city officials who are well-known in the public eye like the mayor, vice mayor, city manager, vice city manager, and members of the city council. A state or a federal elected representative from the city does not qualify.
Flex: City Tests Limits of Restrictive State Law (3 flex points). This category (formerly called “Resisting Dillon’s Rule”) only applies to cities located in states with statewide laws that restrict cities’ authority to pass LGBTQ+-inclusive ordinances. Such cities that take distinct actions to push back against state limits to their ability to pass pro-equality laws will qualify for three flex points in this section. Cities can advocate against restrictive state law through council resolutions or declarations and engagement with state legislators. For more information on preemption laws, please see the issue brief entitled, Power Struggles and Preemption, here or at www.hrc.org/mei.
The Human Rights Campaign reports on news, events and resources of the Human Rights Campaign Foundation that are of interest to the general public and further our common mission to support the LGBTQ community.